Global EditionIndependent source-led reporting · English-language edition
Business / SOURCE REPORT

More Jobs Is Not the Same as Better Jobs

Employment statistics are usually reported as a single number: how many people have jobs. That number matters, and it is a partial measure of what work is like. The ILO’s World Employment and Social Outlook examines global labour-market trends and places them alongside working conditions, inequality, and the uncertainties created by growth, conflict, climate impacts and technology. The gap between having a job and having a decent one is where most of the policy interest lies.

Why the headline hides the story

An unemployment rate counts people actively looking for work. It does not count those who have given up, those working fewer hours than they want, or those in jobs that do not pay enough to live on. A country can report low unemployment while a large share of its workers are in precarious, informal or underpaid work. The headline is not wrong; it is simply answering a narrower question than most readers assume.

More Jobs Is Not the Same as Better Jobs
MonarchErgoIndia / CC0 / Wikimedia Commons

The dimensions of job quality

Job quality combines several attributes. It combines income adequacy, security of tenure, hours, safety, social protection, and voice — the ability to organise and be heard. These dimensions move independently. A job can be well paid and dangerous, secure and poorly paid, flexible and unprotected. That is why a single indicator, such as average wages, can be misleading: it averages across very different working lives.

Informality and social protection

A large share of the world’s workforce is informal, meaning it operates outside the systems that provide pensions, health cover, and protection against dismissal. Informal workers are often the most exposed to shocks and the least able to absorb them. Expanding social protection — through contributory schemes, non-contributory floors, or a mix — is one of the most direct ways to improve job quality at scale, though it is fiscally and politically difficult.

The ILO’s outlook situates labour markets within broader pressures. Conflict and displacement disrupt livelihoods. Climate impacts — heat, floods, drought — reduce working hours and damage the sectors, such as agriculture, where many of the world’s workers are employed. Technological change shifts demand for skills and can displace particular tasks. These forces do not act evenly; they tend to concentrate harm among workers who already have the least protection.

Young people and the transition to work

Youth unemployment is typically higher than the overall rate, and the gap is widest where education systems and labour markets are poorly connected. A first job is where skills are built and networks formed; when that entry is delayed or blocked, the effects persist. Programmes that link training to real demand, and that reduce the cost of hiring inexperienced workers, target this bottleneck directly.

More Jobs Is Not the Same as Better Jobs
Saar Yaacov, GPO / CC BY-SA 3.0 / Wikimedia Commons

Why measurement keeps lagging

Measuring job quality requires data that many countries do not routinely collect: hours, contract type, earnings distribution, injury rates, union coverage. Labour-force surveys focus on employment status rather than on conditions. Filling the gap means investing in survey design and in administrative data from tax and social-security systems. Until then, debates about “good jobs” will rest on partial evidence.

If the goal is decent work rather than merely more work, the levers are familiar but underused: enforceable minimum standards, portable social protection that does not depend on a single employer, active labour-market programmes, and collective bargaining. None of these is a quick fix, and each interacts with the others. The point is that job quantity and job quality can be pursued together, and that treating them as separate concerns is a choice, not a necessity.

What decent work requires

A rising employment count is welcome and insufficient. The question worth asking is not only how many people have work, but what that work provides: enough income, reasonable security, and a measure of dignity. That is a harder thing to measure, which is exactly why it deserves the effort.

More Jobs Is Not the Same as Better Jobs
Ivan Aleskeev / CC BY-SA 4.0 / Wikimedia Commons

Gender and job quality

Job quality is unevenly distributed, and gender is one of the sharpest divides. Women are over-represented in informal and part-time work, under-represented in management, and more likely to carry unpaid care responsibilities that shape what work they can take. The result is a persistent pay gap and a gap in social protection. Because these patterns are structural, they are invisible in a headline employment rate: more women in work can coexist with worse conditions overall if the jobs they enter are precarious. Disaggregating labour data by gender is the minimum needed to see this.

One of the most consistent findings in labour research is that workers who can bargain collectively tend to have better wages, safer conditions and more predictable hours than comparable workers who cannot. This is why the decline of union coverage in many economies is treated as a job-quality issue rather than a narrow labour-relations one. It also explains why measures of voice and representation sit alongside wages in serious assessments of work. A labour market can produce many jobs and weak bargaining power at the same time, and the second condition shapes the quality of the first.

Sources

  • International Labour Organization (ILO). World Employment and Social Outlook. ilo.org
  • ILO. ILOSTAT labour statistics. ilostat.ilo.org

Image: Drivephotographer · CC0 · via Wikimedia Commons.